Skip to Content

How to Make Box Cake Better

Sharing is caring!

Learn how to make box cake mix better with these box cake hacks and tricks! These simple changes can transform your cake. Trust me, don’t miss out on a light, soft, fluffy and moist cake. 

Whether you reach for Betty Crocker Cake mix, Duncan Hines cake mix, or any other brand, these tips work! I have done this for years and always get compliments. 

cake mix, oil and egg on counter

No one has to know you used box cake mix, I won’t tell! Now you might say, tastes better from scratch, and I can agree. But when you adjust the recipe it can truly transform the batter.

Learn how to make box cake taste homemade – soft, fluffy, moist!

Grab my Free Kitchen Version Printable. This teaches you how many cups in a quart, pint, etc. Great to have on hand when baking.

Why Use Box Cake Mix Instead of Homemade Cake

  • Budget friendly 
  • Minimal ingredients needed
  • Easy to adjust recipe to fit needs
  • Delicious and a better cake mix
  • Make boxed cake mix taste like a bakery baked it
cake mix in a pyrex bowl with whisk

Tips For How To Make Boxed Cake Better

Swap Milk For Water

Instead of water, swap with milk. Reach for a whole milk as it will add in fat helping to add richness to the cake. 

The swap is a 1:1 ratio. So 1 cup water on the cake mix box would be switched with 1 cup milk. 

You can even use 2% milk or even skim. I find whole milk offers the best flavor. 

Add Coffee to Chocolate Cake

Adding coffee instead of water is another option. Coffee is going to enhance the chocolate flavor in your cake. 

You will also find adding coffee helps to make the flavor a more decadent dessert. 

Pudding

Mix in a 3.4 oz instant pudding with the cake mix. So for a chocolate cake I would make chocolate pudding. For a vanilla cake I did vanilla pudding, 

Just dump package in and mix up with the rest of the ingredients. It truly enhances the flavor. 

Butter for Oil

Instead of placing oil in the recipe swap for real butter. Just soften or melt down your butter and mix the same.

You can use salted or unsalted butter with no problem! Just make sure it is rea butter and not margarine. 

Mix In Flour and Sugar

You can add in all purpose flour and granulated sugar as well. This is going to help take away the processed flavor of the cake. 

I tend to do around ¼ cup flour and ¼ cup granulated sugar, unless a recipe I am using states otherwise. 

Extra Eggs

The eggs are going to really help make the cake go from tasty to decadent. You will add in your regular eggs as stated on the box. Then add 2 medium-large egg yolks in as additional. 

This adds richness and allows your cake to be moist. 

Sour Cream 

Sour cream is one ingredient I always add to my box cake mix recipes. It is going to help ensure you have a fluffy and ultra-moist cake. Add ½ cup sour cream per box cake mix. 

The sour cream truly is the star of keeping your cake moist but also adds a hint of flavor to the cake. 

Vanilla or Almond Extract 

Adding in ½ teaspoon vanilla or ¼ teaspoon almond extract can transform the flavor. I recommend using the almond on a white cake. It can give you that wedding cake flavor. 

You can always do both in one cake or adjust how much you add to fit your preference of flavor. 

cupcake on white counter

More Creative Ways To Elevate Boxed Cake

Real Frosting instead of Store Bought

Instead of homemade frosting consider making homemade! Buttercream frosting is easy to make and I used it for my lemon cupcakes. 

Just color the frosting with food coloring or leave plain if you want. 

Or go richer and do a cream cheese frosting for even more creamy richness! 

Stir In Ingredients

Adding in items like chocolate chips, a few nuts, chopped fruit, etc. can change up the flavor of a cake. 

Feel free to try it out of your own or find a recipe that helps walk you through how much to add. 

red velvet cake on marble counter

Basics For Doctoring Boxed Cake Mix

Here are the basic changes I start with when working with boxed cake mix. Now, you are more than welcome to use any I listed above. These are just what I do altogether for the optimal flavor of cake. 

  • Swap whole milk for water. 
  • Melted butter for oil 
  • Add 2 extra egg yolks or 1 extra whole egg in addition to what’s on box. 
  • Add in a splash of vanilla extract 

Frequently Asked Questions

Recipes Using Boxed Cake Mix

how to make boxed cake mix taste better

Julia

Saturday 1st of January 2022

These are great tips! Used them on a box birthday cake and tasted so good!!